French legal scholars challenge Le Pen over constitutional shortcut
More than a hundred law professors warn that using Article 11 for constitutional revisions bypasses the rules
By Jonas Lindqvist · Filed Monday, 16 November 2026 · Last updated 19:30 CET
What happened
More than 100 law professors have stepped into France's constitutional arena, publishing a joint intervention in Le Monde to challenge plans by Marine Le Pen to amend the French constitution via referendum.
The 110 signatories warned that relying on Article 11 of the French constitution to alter the country's fundamental law is legally irregular. While the mechanism—which allows the president to submit certain bills directly to a nationwide vote—was famously deployed by Charles de Gaulle in 1962 to introduce direct presidential elections, legal scholars maintain that the text of the constitution does not permit it as an open bypass for constitutional revisions. Le Pen has nevertheless indicated an intention to turn to the de Gaulle-era precedent to put constitutional amendments directly to voters.
Why it matters
For ordinary citizens, how a constitution is changed determines what safeguards protect fundamental rights and the balance of powers. The formal amendment procedure in France requires parliamentary approval before any text goes to a referendum or a joint congressional vote, ensuring that lawmakers review proposed edits before they take effect.
Bypassing parliament through Article 11 effectively turns constitutional reform into a direct contest between the executive and the electorate. While advocates view direct referendums as the purest expression of popular sovereignty, legal scholars argue that ignoring established amendment procedures undermines the rule of law and risks turning the constitution into whatever a single executive decrees it to be.
The Brussels angle
There is no formal EU reaction or ongoing institutional proceeding regarding this domestic French procedural row. However, Brussels observes French institutional balance with intense interest. Any major constitutional shift in a founding member state—particularly one aimed at testing the limits of national sovereignty versus treaties—inevitably reverberates across European institutions, though EU authorities strictly leave national constitutional mechanisms to domestic courts and scholars.
What happens next
The op-ed draws a firm line from the French legal academy against attempts to bypass standard constitutional pathways. If Le Pen eventually secures the presidency and attempts to trigger Article 11 for constitutional reform, the maneuver will face immediate legal challenges, likely requiring France's Constitutional Council to determine whether a Gaullist precedent from six decades ago can legally be revived today.
Written from these sources
Facts are extracted from primary institutional material and written independently by The Gazette desk.
Institutions Correspondent · Council and member states
Jonas LindqvistJonas Lindqvist follows the Council, Coreper and the member-state bargaining that runs late into the night. He specialises in reading the differences between the conclusions and the press conference.
More from Jonas Lindqvist →The Brief
Brussels, decoded, every morning. What happened, what it means, one good dry joke.