Luxembourg Court Takes on 'Free' Digital Services
Advocate General Laila Medina delivers her legal opinion in a German consumer watchdog dispute over digital costs
By Nina Marchetti · Filed Saturday, 21 November 2026 · Last updated 12:45 CET
What happened
Advocate General Laila Medina of the Court of Justice of the European Union has issued her formal legal opinion in Case C-643/25. The preliminary ruling request stems from a challenge initiated by Germany's federal consumer federation, the Verbraucherzentrale Bundesverband, over commercial rules governing "free" digital offerings.
Why it matters
In the digital single market, services marketed as zero-cost routinely extract value through user data rather than bank accounts, drawing scrutiny over whether calling them "free" misleads buyers under European consumer law. While an Advocate General does not decide the dispute, their independent legal assessment forms the intellectual scaffolding for the final decision. When Luxembourg defines what can be advertised as free, that standard instantly binds commercial practices across all 27 member states.
The Brussels angle
In the Luxembourg machinery, an Advocate General is tasked with offering a completely impartial legal solution to the court before the judges disappear to deliberate—a rare luxury in a town where almost everyone else is frantically bargaining. National watchdogs like Germany's Verbraucherzentrale have increasingly mastered this route, using preliminary references to extract continent-wide consumer rights directly from judges instead of waiting years for Commission directives to crawl through legislative negotiations.
What happens next
The judges of the Court of Justice will deliberate in private to prepare their definitive judgment in Case C-643/25. The bench is not bound to adopt Medina’s recommendations, though it routinely follows the Advocate General's reasoning in the vast majority of cases before referring the final verdict back to the national court.
Written from these sources
Facts are extracted from primary institutional material and written independently by The Gazette desk.
Explainer Desk Editor · EU 101 and What It Means
Nina MarchettiNina Marchetti edits the Explainer Desk, turning complicated EU announcements into plain English for readers who have never sat through a Commission briefing.
More from Nina Marchetti →The Brief
Brussels, decoded, every morning. What happened, what it means, one good dry joke.