Think Tank Warns Border Guards Alone Cannot Stamp Out Europe's Black Market
A new report argues that clamping down at the frontier fails unless regulators strip illicit sellers of their regulatory price advantage
By Katarzyna Wisniewska · Filed Saturday, 21 November 2026 · Last updated 14:00 CET
What happened
Relying purely on customs checkpoints will not choke off Europe's illicit trade, according to research released by the Hermes European Study Centre. In a paper published on 13 November, the research body argues that combating the black market requires a two-pronged overhaul: simplifying the rulebook for legitimate businesses while significantly stepping up market enforcement. Under the study's findings, overly complex compliance regimes perversely subsidise illegal traders, granting them a built-in price advantage over lawful European companies that bear the mounting costs of compliance.
Why it matters
For consumers and legitimate manufacturers, illicit goods are not just a policing issue; they distort the internal market. When lawful businesses face labyrinthine compliance obligations, illegal competitors operate outside those costs entirely, undercutting market prices. The study contends that levelling the playing field demands more than intercepting freight containers at ports. True deterrence requires rules simple enough for honest businesses to afford, paired with the domestic enforcement needed to deprive rogue operators of their profit margins.
The Brussels angle
The paper taps into a perennial Brussels tension: the instinct to solve every regulatory challenge by adding new obligations, balanced against the stubborn reality that criminals rarely submit paperwork. While EU policymakers frequently focus on frontier oversight and customs modernisation, think tanks and industry lobbies increasingly argue that red tape acts as an indirect tariff on compliance. In institutional parlance, border management cannot compensate for internal market frictions.
What happens next
The findings feed into ongoing debates across European business federations and policy circles over competitiveness, regulatory simplification, and market surveillance across the 27 member states.
Written from these sources
Facts are extracted from primary institutional material and written independently by The Gazette desk.
Correspondent, The Brussels Bubble · Bubble politics and manoeuvring
Katarzyna WisniewskaKatarzyna Wisniewska writes The Brussels Bubble: the rivalries, leaks, coalitions and diplomacy practised off the record in and around the institutions.
More from Katarzyna Wisniewska →The Brief
Brussels, decoded, every morning. What happened, what it means, one good dry joke.